OSIA opposes Endorsement of OOXML as an ISO standard
Brendan Scott, on behalf of Open Source Industry Australia Ltd makes this submissions to Standards Australia on the matter of endorsing ISO
OSIA suggests that Standards Australia should not support endorsement of the OOXML format as an ISO Standard at this time. OSIA believes endorsement of OOXML as an ISO Standard would create a number of issues including:
(a) the large number of existing contradictions and criticisms of the format are so numerous and are sufficiently serious to warrant rejection;
(b) endorsement will create confusion among Australian consumers of office applications;
(c) endorsement will result in legal issues under s 52 of the Trade Practices Act for Australian businesses making representations about such an endorsement;
(d) endorsement will be unfair to potential implementers;
(e) endorsement will disadvantage Australian vendors; and
(f) endorsement would place Standards Australia in a difficult position.
In addition, to the extent the existence of translators may be argued to alleviate any of these issues, the format is redundant and should be rejected for that reason.